|
HEAD TO HEAD |
Lacerte vs UltraTax CS: a side-by-side buying guide for CPA firms
Both products scored within one point of each other on Audit Friendly's scale - the differences that matter are price structure, ecosystem fit and how far cloud-native
Lacerte and UltraTax CS are the two most-used professional tax engines among AICPA members, according to the Journal of Accountancy's 2026 survey of 1,808 CPA respondents. UltraTax CS was named by 22.3 percent of respondents; Lacerte by 16.7 percent. Both received an Audit Friendly score in the mid-70s - 75 for Lacerte, 74 for UltraTax CS - and both drew the same top complaint from their own users: price. In that survey, more than 80 percent of Lacerte users and 80.5 percent of UltraTax CS users named price as a top dislike. That shared grievance is where the comparison gets interesting, because the two products charge differently enough that the better value depends entirely on volume and mix.
BY THE NUMBERS
|
75/100 AF SCORE, LACERTE |
74/100 AF SCORE, ULTRATAX CS |
|
$599 LACERTE PRICING, AS REVIEWED |
1979 ULTRATAX CS IN MARKET SINCE |
HEAD TO HEAD
Lacerte vs UltraTax CS
From the Audit Friendly reviews of each; follow the links for sources.
| Lacerte | UltraTax CS | |
| AF SCORE | 75/100 | 74/100 |
| IN MARKET SINCE | 1978 | 1979 |
| HIRED FOR | Lacerte transfers K-1 data from business returns into partners' 1040s and emails each partner a secure link to their K-1 package. | UltraTax CS uses an apportionment grid for business returns and a multistate allocation grid for Schedule C or K-1 income. |
| PRICING MODEL | Annual license plus per-return fees, or quoted bundles | Quote only: license or pay-per-return, by users and states |
| IMPLEMENTATION | Intuit converts prior-year client data from 10 named packages at no extra cost, usually within 1 to 3 business days, and its Easy Start team runs... | Thomson Reuters' Tax Data Conversion Service converts the two most recent years of competitor data, usually starting in July, and each conversion... |
| AGENT READINESS | Exists: No first-party MCP server for Lacerte was listed in the official MCP registry or on GitHub when checked on 4 October 2026. | Exists: No. Thomson Reuters publishes no MCP server for UltraTax CS, and the official MCP registry returns no UltraTax or Thomson Reuters tax entry... |
| WHERE IT LOSES | Price-sensitive sole practitioners filing mostly simple 1040s; Drake Tax 1040 lists unlimited individual returns at $2,325 for tax year 2026, rising... | Sole preparers on a tight budget: Drake Tax publishes its unlimited single-user Pro package at $2,845 retail for tax year 2026 ($2,695 before 1... |
Lacerte publishes its pay-per-return fees: a $599 annual license, then $105 per Form 1040 with one state, $148 per business, fiduciary or exempt return with one state, and $99 per 706 or 709 (checked 4 October 2026). Extra states and consolidated corporate returns add further per-return charges. Bundle and unlimited plans exist but are quoted, not listed. UltraTax CS publishes nothing - custom pricing based on users, returns and states, with e-filing, eSignature and organizer transmissions carrying additional fees visible only inside CS Connect after sign-in. Lacerte's published rates make modeling easier before you call a sales rep; UltraTax CS's opacity makes early-stage comparison harder but rewards firms that negotiate on volume. On the forms side, Lacerte claims 7,200-plus forms and 25,000-plus diagnostics; UltraTax CS covers 1040, 1065, 1120, 1120-S, 1041, 990, 706, 709 and 5500 and e-files more than 371 state and local returns, per Thomson Reuters.
Where the products diverge most is ecosystem. Lacerte is an Intuit product running on Windows PCs or Rightworks hosting, and its planning connection is to Intuit Tax Advisor. Its K-1 workflow is a genuine differentiator: it transfers K-1 data from business returns into partners' 1040s and emails each partner a secure link to their K-1 package - Intuit says this saved firms an average of 5.6 hours based on 2024 usage data from 12,500 firms, though no independent source confirms that figure. UltraTax CS sits at the center of Thomson Reuters' CS Professional Suite. Data sharing by tax ID links 1120-S and 1065 data into owner returns without rekeying, and the value compounds for firms that also run Accounting CS, Workpapers CS, Practice CS, SafeSend and SurePrep - one client list, one data flow. A firm already deep in that suite has a switching cost that Lacerte's K-1 automation alone will not overcome.
On agent readiness, both products are at the same early stage: none. No first-party MCP server exists for Lacerte in the official registry or on GitHub as of 4 October 2026; Intuit's public MCP server covers QuickBooks Online only. UltraTax CS has no MCP server either; Thomson Reuters' CoCounsel connector serves legal research and does not reach tax returns. A CoCounsel integration that sends printed returns to CoCounsel is listed in the UltraTax CS help center as coming soon, with no date given. Firms betting on AI agents to prepare or queue e-files through an API will not find that capability in either product today. The decision rule, then, is structural: if your firm is Windows-based, does partnership and estate work at moderate volume and wants published per-return pricing, Lacerte fits. If you have six or more preparers already running CS Professional Suite products and want one shared client list across compliance, workpapers and practice management, UltraTax CS is the harder product to walk away from - but get the full quote in writing, by state and return type, before you commit.
HOW TO DECIDE
| Ask Lacerte for a bundle quote: pay-per-return math gets expensive above roughly 100 returns. | |
| Ask UltraTax CS for the CS Connect fee schedule before signing - e-file and eSignature costs are not in the base quote. | |
| Confirm your target vendor converts the other's data before giving notice on the one you are leaving. |
SPONSORED
QUESTIONS THIS ANSWERS
What does Lacerte cost for a typical accounting firm?
Pay-per-return pricing is published: a $599 annual license, then $105 per Form 1040 and $148 per business, fiduciary or exempt return, each including one state and e-file (published, checked 4 October 2026). A firm filing 100 individual and 30 business returns that way would pay about $15,539 a year before extra states, hosting or add-ons (Audit Friendly estimate). Bundles of returns and unlimited plans with all states are quote only. Intuit says bundles usually cost less than buying each piece separately, and the unlimited plan includes Tax Planner and Analyzer. Hosting starts at $80 a month...
What does UltraTax CS cost for a typical CPA firm?
Thomson Reuters does not publish a price. The product page says custom pricing is based on the number of users, tax returns, and states and jurisdictions (checked 4 October 2026). Firms choose a full license or a pay-per-return license, and e-filing, eSignature and organizer transmissions marked ($) in CS Connect carry extra fees. The detailed CS Professional Suite price list opens only after a customer signs in, and no product-specific public benchmark was found. In the JofA 2026 survey, 80.5 percent of UltraTax CS users named price a top dislike. Ask for a written quote by state, return...
SOURCES
Where this comes from
Then the UltraTax CS review; both link their sources.
GO DEEPER
Go deeper
Built from the Audit Friendly software review, a fact-checked vendor pack maintained by our research agents; the review page carries every source.
The modern accounting tech stack: tools, automations and workflows shaping the next generation of finance operations.
Modern Accounting · Audit Friendly Data · Accounting & Finance Jobs
Audit Friendly · accountingstack.ai